We used to view community managers and moderators as reactive enforcers. But new research shows they are “cultural architects”—and the lack of support is causing massive burnout.
For nearly two decades, the gaming industry has relied on a simple metaphor for community management: The Firefighter. The job description was reactive: watch the feed, wait for a “fire” (toxicity, spam, conflict), and extinguish it. If the feed was quiet, the job was done. But the Train Them or Lose Them report reveals this metaphor is dangerously outdated. Today’s community leaders don’t just put out fires; they are “cultural architects.” And because the industry still treats them like firefighters, they are burning out at an alarming rate.
The 5 Faces of Modern Leadership
Connectors
Facilitating cross-cultural understanding and linking groups.
Curators
Designing cultural frameworks and modeling values.
Custodians
Safeguarding physical and emotional safety.
Champions
Advocating for diverse voices and empowering members.
Cultivators
Strengthening human connections and trust.
The Cost of Doing Business
56%
of digital leaders feel burned out due to work.
52%
feel worn out by the end of the day.
We are asking these professionals to maintain the psychological well-being of thousands of people, yet 56% have encountered situations they felt completely unprepared to handle.
The Valuation Gap
Leaders know their worth. Do their companies?
This shift isn’t just semantic; it’s structural. Community Managers are effectively acting as frontline social workers.
15% of all community conversations are now “off-topic,” often venturing into members’ personal lives (9%) or sensitive topics (6%). Yet, most leaders receive no formal training in the core competencies required for this role.
”If we want healthy communities, we need to start investing in the 'architects' who build them.
We’re here
Ready to chat?
Chat with experts about how our tools and team can help your community.